A running toilet is one of the more expensive quiet sounds in a house. A thin, endless trickle into the bowl can waste tens of litres a day, and a valve that never shuts off can waste far more than that. The good news is that most running toilets are tank problems, not bowl problems, and the parts are standard, inexpensive, and meant to be replaced by a careful homeowner.
You do not need to replace the whole toilet. You usually need to look at three pieces: the flapper (or flush valve seal) at the bottom of the tank, the chain that lifts it, and the fill valve that refills the tank and is supposed to stop at a marked water line.
Shut the water off at the toilet's supply valve before you take anything apart, then flush to empty most of the tank. The remaining water can be sponged out. Do not overtighten tank bolts or the supply nut on porcelain — the tank can crack, and a cracked tank is no longer a small repair. If the toilet is old, the supply line is corroded, or the shutoff valve itself will not turn, stop and call a licensed plumber.
Listen before you unscrew anything
Lift the tank lid and set it somewhere safe; those lids chip easily. Then listen and look:
- The tank empties slowly into the bowl, or you hear a faint hiss and occasional "phantom" refill. The flapper is not sealing. Water leaks into the bowl, the level in the tank drops, and the fill valve wakes up to top it off.
- Water is coming out of the overflow tube in the middle of the tank. The fill valve is set too high, or it is not shutting off, and the extra water is spilling down the tube on purpose so the tank cannot overflow onto the floor.
- The fill valve never quite goes quiet. The valve itself is worn, dirty, or mis-set, even if the water line looks reasonable.
Dye can confirm a silent flapper leak. Put a few drops of food colouring in the tank, wait 15 to 20 minutes without flushing, and look in the bowl. If the colour shows up there, the flapper (or the seat it closes against) is leaking.
Start with the flapper and chain
The flapper is the rubber or silicone cap that covers the big opening at the bottom of the tank. It stiffens, warps, and gets slimy with age, especially in hard water or with some in-tank cleaning tablets, which are hard on rubber.
Turn the supply off and flush. Pinch the flapper off its two side ears, or unhook it the way the old one was attached — some sit on a ring around the overflow tube. Take the old flapper with you when you buy a replacement. Sizes are common, but the ear style and the shape of the seal are not all the same. A universal flapper works on many toilets; a few brands want their own shape.
Clean the rim of the flush valve seat with a non-scratch pad or a cloth. Mineral crust on that ring will defeat a brand-new flapper. Install the new flapper so it sits square and can fall closed under its own weight.
Then set the chain. There should be a little slack — roughly 1 centimetre — when the flapper is closed. Too tight, and the flapper cannot seal. Too loose, and the flapper will not lift enough to flush, or the chain can slip under the flapper and hold it open. Hook the chain so it does not catch on the fill-valve float or the overflow tube.
Turn the water back on, let the tank fill, and wait. If the hiss is gone and a dye test stays clean, you are done.
Set the water level
Look for a mark on the overflow tube or a water-level line moulded into the tank. The water should sit about 2 centimetres below the top of the overflow tube, not even with it and not pouring into it.
How you adjust the level depends on the fill valve:
- A float ball on an arm (common in older tanks) usually has a screw at the arm or a simple bend. You want the ball to rise and shut the valve before water reaches the overflow. Bend the metal arm gently downward to lower the level; do not kink it sharply.
- A float cup that slides on the fill-valve shaft (common on later valves, including many Fluidmaster-style units) usually has a metal clip. Pinch the clip and slide the cup down to lower the water line, then let the tank refill and check.
- Some valves have a screw on top for fine adjustment. A quarter turn at a time is enough.
If lowering the level stops water from spilling down the overflow and the valve shuts off cleanly, you may not need a new valve. If the valve keeps running with the float held all the way up — use a hand to lift it — the valve is not sealing and should be replaced.
Replace a worn fill valve
A modern fill-valve kit is a single column that drops into the tank and comes with instructions. You do not have to match the 20-year-old brand. Measure roughly how tall the tank is, or buy an adjustable universal valve, which covers most residential toilets.
Turn the water off. Flush and sponge the tank almost dry. Put a towel and a small bucket under the supply connection. Disconnect the supply line from the tailpiece under the tank. Hold the valve inside the tank so it cannot spin, and unscrew the lock nut underneath. Lift the old valve out.
Install the new valve at the height the instructions specify, usually with the top of the valve a little above the overflow tube. Hand-tighten the lock nut, then a small extra snug with pliers — not a big heave. Reattach the supply line with a new washer if the old one looks crushed. Hook the refill tube so it clips to the overflow tube and aims down into it, not down into the tank in a way that siphons, and not so far into the overflow that it is jammed.
Turn the water on, check for drips under the tank, and set the water level as above. Flush a few times and watch the refill. The valve should open, fill, and go fully quiet.
If the supply line is old chromed copper with a cracked nut, or if it twists as you loosen it, replace the line with a new braided stainless flex line at the same time. They are inexpensive and they fail in a messier way than a flapper does.
Small problems that look like a running toilet
A chain hooked under a flapper will keep the toilet running after some flushes but not others. A refill tube that has popped off will spray around the tank and can start a siphon. A loose tank-to-bowl connection is a different leak — water on the floor, not a hiss in the bowl — and the tank bolts and the large sponge gasket between tank and bowl need attention. If you see water at the base of the toilet or along the floor, that is not a running-tank problem; stop and assess before you keep flushing.
Hard water, common in some Ontario and prairie cities and in many well systems, leaves a crust on the flush-valve seat and inside the fill valve. Cleaning the seat and replacing the valve usually beats trying to soak antique parts back to life.
When to call a plumber
Call a licensed plumber if the shutoff valve under the tank will not turn or starts to leak when you try, if the tank or bowl is cracked, if water is leaking between the tank and the bowl and a careful gasket replacement is more than you want to take on, or if a new flapper will not seal because the flush-valve seat itself is pitted or broken. That seat is replaceable on many toilets, but it is a bigger job, and a chipped porcelain horn is easy to create if you rush it.
A running toilet in an unheated cottage or a cold garage bathroom can also be a freeze risk in winter, because a thin trickle is not the same as a planned drip on a vulnerable line. If that is the setting, read how to prevent frozen pipes after you stop the waste.
Once the tank stays quiet, you have removed a surprisingly large water leak. If a nearby faucet is dripping as well, fix it with the same patience and the same habit of shutting the water off first: how to fix a leaky faucet.