A squeaky door is almost always a hinge problem, not a "door" problem. Metal rubs on metal, or a dry pin turns in a dry barrel, and the sound carries through a quiet house. The fix is usually a cleaning and a proper lubricant, sometimes followed by a couple of longer screws. It is a short job, and it is one of the more satisfying ones, because you can hear the result immediately.

If the door also scrapes the floor or the latch misses the strike, that is a different issue — sticking or sagging — and you should treat it as a sticking door after you quiet the hinge.

Safety

Support the door if you plan to take more than one pin out at a time, especially a solid-core or exterior door. Those doors are heavy, and a hinge that slips can pinch fingers or twist the remaining screws out of the frame. Keep a helper or a wedge under the door if you are going further than a single pin.

Find which hinge is talking

Open and close the door slowly and listen with a hand on each hinge in turn. You can often feel the vibration in the noisy one. Interior doors usually have two or three butt hinges; a slightly loose top hinge is a frequent culprit because it carries more of the door's weight.

Check the screws first, before you buy anything. A hinge that has worked itself loose will squeak and also sag. Tighten every screw with a screwdriver that actually fits — a stripped head is a worse problem than a squeak. If a screw just spins, the hole is worn. Replace that screw with a longer one that reaches the framing behind the jamb, often a 50 to 75 millimetre (2 to 3 inch) wood screw, driven carefully so you do not punch through a visible door casing on the other side. One or two long screws in the top hinge will often pull a sagging door back into line and reduce the rub that was causing the noise.

Take the pin out and clean it

A spray of household water-displacing oil on a closed hinge will quiet a door for a few days and then collect dust. It is a decent emergency measure and a poor long-term one. Better to pull the pin, wipe the old dirt off, and put a grease or a dry lubricant where the metal actually turns.

Close the door. Most pins come out from the bottom or can be driven up from the underside with a nail set and a light hammer. Put a finger under the head if it is already proud, or tap a thin flat screwdriver under the mushroom head. Work the pin up a little at a time. If it is painted in place, score the paint line with a utility knife so you do not chip a big flake off the hinge or the jamb.

Pull the pin. Wipe it with a rag. If it is gummy or rusty, scrub it with an old toothbrush and a little mineral spirits or even soapy water, then dry it completely. Look down the hinge barrels. A clot of old paint, hair, or rust in there will keep singing after you oil the pin. A cotton swab or a rolled bit of cloth will reach it.

Tip

If a pin will not move, do not beat the hinge into a banana shape. Remove the hinge leaves from the door and jamb (with the door supported) and drive the pin out on the bench, or replace that hinge as a set. Hinges are sold in pairs or threes with matching pins, and a single mismatched pin is often looser or tighter than the others.

Lubricate the parts that slide

The right lubricant is one that stays on the pin and does not drip onto the floor.

  • White lithium grease is an excellent ordinary choice for household hinges. A thin film on the pin is enough.
  • Silicone spray or a silicone grease works well and is less likely to stain, which matters on a pale paint or a wood door you care about.
  • A dry PTFE or graphite lubricant is useful where you do not want a wet film, such as a hinge that collects lint.

Apply a thin coat, reinsert the pin all the way, and wipe the excess. Open and close the door twenty times to work the lubricant in, then wipe again. If you can still hear a dry chirp, pull the pin on the next hinge and treat it too. It is often worth doing all of them once you have the rag out.

Avoid dumping oil into a hinge and hoping. Excess oil runs, then turns into a grey collar of dust at the bottom of the barrel, which is both ugly and a new source of noise.

Do not use cooking oil or butter. They go rancid, collect dirt, and eventually make a worse mess than the squeak.

Painted-shut hinges and winter noises

In older Canadian houses, hinges are often buried under decades of paint. Paint on the knuckle can squeak like dry metal. After you score the paint at the moving joint, work the door back and forth and pick the loose chips out of the barrel before you lubricate. If the hinge is so caked that it will not close fully, that is also a cause of sticking, and the paint buildup on the door edge or the jamb may need to be sanded.

Winter adds its own soundtrack. A heated house in January is dry; wood shrinks, a door can loosen on its hinges, and a pin that was quiet in humid July may start to rub. The same cleaning-and-grease routine applies. If the door rattles in the latch as well as squeaks, the strike plate may need a small adjustment, but start with the hinges — they are the moving parts.

A storm door or a cold-entrance door can squeak because the closer, not the hinge, is dry. Those closers usually have a specific lubricant recommendation; a general spray can swell some seals. Check the closer's instructions before you oil it, and do not prop a storm door open against a closer that is already struggling.

When to replace the hinge

Replace the hinge if the barrel is cracked, if the pin is bent, if the knuckles are so worn that the door drops as soon as you lift it, or if rust has pitted the pin badly. Replace hinges as a set on that door so the pins match. For an exterior door, buy hinges rated for the door's weight and, if it is a fire-rated door, do not substitute a lighter decorative hinge.

A tight, quiet hinge will not hide a door that is hitting the latch or the floor. If the squeak is gone and the door still misbehaves, move on to the sticking-door guide rather than adding more grease. And if removing a hinge has left torn screw holes in a visible jamb, fill them properly or move the hinge a little, and patch as you would any other small wall or trim wound — see how to patch drywall if the damage has crept onto the wall itself.