The bead of caulk around a bathtub is a thin line doing a serious job. It keeps splash water from creeping behind the tub and into the wall, where it is slow to dry and expensive to repair. When the bead cracks, peels, or grows dark stains, water has a path. Recaulking is a cosmetic job only if the joint was merely ugly. If the wall has been wet for a long time, it can also be a diagnostic job.
A good bead depends less on "a steady hand" than on a clean, dry joint and the right product. Most failed DIY caulk jobs fail because new silicone was laid on top of dirty, damp, or leftover old caulk, or because the shower was used before the new bead had cured.
Do not slice toward yourself, and be careful with a razor on acrylic or fibreglass tubs — a metal blade can gouge the finish. If you lift the old bead and find wet, stained, or crumbling drywall, a soft tub lip, or a persistent musty smell, stop decorating and find out where the water is going. Hidden moisture can mean mould inside the wall. A large, wet, or structurally soft area is a reason to call a professional, not to seal the evidence in with a prettier bead.
Choose the right caulk
For the joint between a tub or shower and the wall, use 100% silicone that is labelled for kitchens and bathrooms and mildew-resistant. Silicone stays flexible when the tub flexes under a person's weight, which acrylic and fibreglass tubs do. Ordinary painter's acrylic latex caulk is the wrong material here. It is easier to tool and to clean up, and it will fail in a wet joint.
Do not use silicone on a surface you intend to paint; paint will not stick to it. The tub joint is almost never painted, so that limitation is fine. If you are sealing a painted window or a baseboard, pick a different, paintable product.
A small tube is enough for one tub. Check the expiry date. Old silicone that has started to skin in the nozzle will drag and pock.
Take the old bead off, completely
New caulk will not bond well to old caulk. Cut along both edges of the old bead with a utility knife, shallow and controlled, then pull. A plastic caulk-removal tool helps you lift the ribbon without scarring the tub. Work in short sections. Pick the remaining crumbs out of the joint with a plastic scraper or a wooden stick.
If someone caulked over soap scum last time, you will also be scraping film. Household residue plus leftover silicone is a classic reason a new bead peels in a sheet two months later.
Vacuum or wipe the loose debris. Then clean the joint with a rag and isopropyl alcohol, or a cleaner the tub manufacturer allows, and let it dry. If dark staining remains on grout next to the joint, clean that as a grout and mould problem before you seal the edge, or you will trap the stain under a clear edge of silicone.
Dry is not optional
Silicone needs a dry surface. After you clean, wait. In a Canadian house in January the air may be dry enough that an hour will do. In a tightly sealed bathroom without a working fan, wait longer — overnight is reasonable if the area has been wet. Run the exhaust fan. Wipe the joint again just before you start.
If the tub is against an exterior wall and the room stays chronically damp, fixing the ventilation matters as much as the bead. A perfect bead in a room that never dries will still grow mildew on the surface.
Tape, cut the nozzle, and lay a continuous bead
Painter's tape on both sides of the joint, leaving a neat gap the width you want the finished bead to be, is the closest thing this job has to a guarantee. Press the tape down firmly so silicone cannot bleed under it.
Cut the nozzle at a 45-degree angle, with an opening slightly smaller than you think you need. You can always cut it a little larger; you cannot make it smaller. Puncture the inner seal. Load the tube in a caulk gun and run a test bead on a piece of cardboard.
Start at one corner and push or pull the gun along the joint in a steady motion, slightly overfilling the gap. Keep the tip in the bead as you go so you do not leave air pockets. A continuous bead around the three walls is better than a series of dabs. Where the tub meets the floor, caulk only if that joint is designed to be sealed; some tub skirts and tiles want a clear gap. Match what was there if the original installation was sound.
Tool it, then leave it alone
Tool the bead while it is still wet. The traditional method is a finger dipped in a little soapy water, drawn smoothly along the joint. Plastic tooling sticks also work and keep silicone off your skin. You want the caulk pressed into the joint, with a slightly concave face, and the excess on the tape, not smeared up the tiles.
Pull the painter's tape immediately, at a shallow angle, before the silicone skins. If you wait until it cures, the tape will tear the edge. Touch up a small gap with a tiny bit of fresh caulk; do not keep fussing a setting bead or you will leave ridges.
Wipe stray silicone off the tub and tiles now, with the solvent the label allows (often mineral spirits for uncured silicone, used sparingly and away from acrylic if the manufacturer forbids it). Cured silicone is miserable to remove.
A gap that is too deep — more than about 8 or 10 millimetres — needs a foam backer rod pushed into the joint first, so the silicone has a proper shape to sit on rather than a cavern to fall into. A huge void behind the tub lip is not something to fill from a caulk tube; that can be a sign the tub was not set correctly.
Cure time, and the first shower
Read the tube. Many bathroom silicones need 24 hours before the joint sees water, and some want longer in cool, damp rooms. The surface can feel dry to the touch much earlier; that is not the same as cured. Plan the job for a morning when everyone can use a different shower, or can take a careful bath that does not splash the new bead.
If the bead grows mildew on the surface later, clean it gently and improve the drying time of the room. Surface mildew is not automatically a failed seal. A bead that shrinks away from the tile, cracks, or lets water darken the wall is a failed seal and should be removed and done again, not painted over.
When caulk is not the real repair
If the wallboard at the tub lip is soft, if tiles are loose, if water appears in the ceiling below after every shower, or if you can squeeze wet material out of the joint, the problem is behind the finish. Recaulking might slow it down, and it might also close the only visible warning. Hire a licensed plumber or a contractor who can open the wall carefully, fix the leak, and replace damaged board with something suitable for a wet area.
A tub that meets a freshly patched wall should be recaulked after the drywall patch is primed and painted, not before. And if water is pooling because the drain is slow, clear that first: how to unclog a drain without chemicals. A perfect bead will not save a bathroom that stays wet for hours after every shower.